[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

RE: How do we take it forward? You tell us!

My point earlier was that it would be useful if we in our discussion
demonstrate respect for others opinions. If we do not do that, how can
expects the rest of the world to take the group seriously?


> ----------
> From:         Sanjeev Sabhlok[SMTP:sabhlok@almaak.usc.edu]
> Reply To:     debate@indiapolicy.org
> Sent:         Sunday, November 29, 1998 1:48 PM
> To:   debate@indiapolicy.org
> Subject:      How do we take it forward? You tell us!
> On Sat, 28 Nov 1998, Shashi Shekhar wrote:
> > Leveraging Internet based Technologies to build "Community Networks"

> > which can then become vehicles of change.
>               etc. etc.
> > There it is guys, how do we take it forward
> Shashi, That was a nice piece of wishful thinking!
> I was talking with Vamsi over the phone a while ago and I have a small

> similie for all of us to consider:
> The technology to go to the moon existed in the 1960s.
> So also the knowledge to change India exists today.
> The knowledge to create community networks exists today.
> The problem is
>       a) somebody has to visualize it
>       b) somebody has to create a plan and strategy for it
>       c) somebody has to enthuse people to join in the plan
>       d) somebody has to work out the details
>       e) somebody has to do the dirty work of actually making
>               the spacecraft
>       f) somebody has to risk their lives and go to the moon.
> In other words, we have to not only show that a technology exists, we
> have to show how we can do it.
> In this case, I see this idea as highly impractical. It is a costly
> idea.  It is trying to provide a public good, ie., there is no
> for private citizens to build this network: e.g., providing computers
> and T3 lines to villages in India. etc. etc.
> I am being a devil's advocate; not being harsh. Think of why your idea

> is economic, worthwhile, feasible, and how it will be implemented. Try

> to persuade me. Try to persuade others. Show how it will be done.
> Else, like much that we would like to see (such as free education for
> everyone, right to education, free water for everyone, etc., etc.,) it

> will only provide a leverage for those who see a role for government
> opening a new department with the intention of providing computers
> of cost in every village! (basically a free sinecure to some petty
> servant somewhere!)
> Good intentions must be really good. They must also be supportable
> without govt. intervention.
> There. I am now waiting to be persuaded.
> Sanjeev

This is the National Debate on System Reform.       debate@indiapolicy.org
Rules, Procedures, Archives:            http://www.indiapolicy.org/debate/