[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: An Open Letter to Shri Chowgule

Postings not related to the writing of the Manifesto or policy chapters
are likely to be summarily rejected. Thanks for your understanding. IPI
I am not sure that we can take seriously a report that claims that the state 
government as well as the state police are part of a conspiracy inspired from 
abroad against the central government.  

While the report raises some important questions of detail, to which I would be 
interested to have answers, I know that I, at least, cannot take the report 
seriously overall.

Professor Prabhu Guptara
Director, Executive and Organisational Development
Wolfsberg Executive Development Centre
(a subsidiary of UBS AG)
CH-8272 Ermatingen
Tel: +41.71.663.5605
Fax: +41.71.663.5594
e-mail: prabhu.guptara@ubs.com
INTERNET: http://www.wolfsberg.com

______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________
Subject: Re: An Open Letter to Shri Chowgule
Author:  loraln (loraln@worldnet.att.net) at unix,mime
Date:    03.02.99 06:12

Postings not related to the writing of the Manifesto or policy chapters 
are likely to be summarily rejected. Thanks for your understanding. IPI 
Professor Subroto Roy wrote:
>Dear Shri Chowgule,
>You have been quoted in the press as having said that the Australian 
>missionary Mr. Graham Staines had "brandished" a pistol, whereas his 
>has been quoted as having said he could not have done as he had none. 
>debate at IPI has touched upon the killing of Mr. Staines and I wonder 
>you may be so kind as to inform us of the answers to these questions 
>1.  Have you been quoted correctly?
>2.  If so, what is the basis in evidence of the information that Mr. 
>had brandished a firearm?
>3.  Even if he had done so, would that not have been justified in 
>self-defence and in defence of his children?
>4.  In general, does the VHP's interpretation of our common Hindu 
>beliefs or
>doctrines suggest there to be no right of self-defence? 
Another newsgroup has produced a detailed report on the incident as 
published in an Oriya Weekly, RASHTRADEEP. This report provides many 
hitherto unknown facts relevant to Professor Roy's posers. The report is
reproduced below:
Ram Narayanan
(From a Oriya Weekly from Cuttack, Orissa, on Jan 26, 1999.)
Australian Father Burnt Alive: Spot Report from Manoharpur
Manoharpur is a remote village of Keonjhar district, Odisha which is 100
kms from district headquarter Keonjhargarh, 46 kms from the 
sub-divisional head quarter Anandapur.  It is very poorly communicated. 
It is border village of both Mayurbhanj and Keonjhar district.  These 
two sister districts were ruled by Bhanja dynasty, having native tribes 
of Bhuyans, Santhals and Majhis.  These tribes are very much cultured 
and disciplined.  Several times they revolted against injustice and 
foreign rule.  They pray God in the name of nature, plants and soil 
(Motherland) & natural resources are plenty till today.  Always these 
tribes think themselves as the kingmaker and saviour of royal dynasty.
Graham Stewart Steins
Australian father Graham Steins came to Odisha in Jan 1965.  He 
established his centre at Baripada the dist.  Head quarter of 
Mayurbhanj, famous as a cultured town of mother Odisha.  Graham started 
his missionary work through Evangelical Mission, Baptist Church (at 
Baripada), World Vision of India with a coverage of leprosy centre at 
Baripada which is not at all a leprosy prone area.  In 1980 he 
established a missionary Church (Thatched house) at Manoharpur (Kacha 
Sahi) about 150 kms from Baripada, and recently VRO and NGO is suspected
to be working for conversion.  His family consisted of Mr.  Graham 
Stewart Steins (55), his wife-Glades Steins (45), daughter Easter (13), 
son Philips Steins (12) & Timoti Steins (9).  Though Steins family have 
been staying here since last 34 years they did not take the citizenship 
of India.  Every time administration was in difficult position to deal 
him as he stayed in Mayurbhanj dist, but operating in Keonjhar district.
Conversion Started
The Baripada Mission Church leader is Nimain Hansda.  His sister got 
married to Shyam Marandi of Manoharpur and became Martha Marandi. 
Through her Graham started converting Hindu Santhals (tribe) in 
Manoharpur and adjacent area.  Latest position of converted Santhals and
Kolha in that area - (which was 100% non-Christian in 1980):
Manoharpur - 24 families, Sanakusapada - 6, Tulasibani - 15, Baniajodi -
3, Palabani - 3, Pathaveda - 5.  Now 56 families were converted at a 
Conversion Process
Contact persons gather them in Jungle Camp for 3-4 days, allow all young
girls & boys to stay together, perform marriages, preach Bible, show 
video and audio films of Jesus Christ and finally convert them through 
This years' Jungle Camp (Mela)
This year Graham Steins organised Jungle camp from Jan 20 to 24th, 
1999.  Everyday there was a feast of meat and rice with local alcoholic
preparation Handia.  Massive drive of meetings and showing of films were
conducted for 3 to 4 days.  400 people were targeted to be converted on 
24th Jan.  56 families were converted on 22nd.  Every thing was under 
the leadership of Graham Stewart Steins and his battalion of 10 
preachers from Cuttack and Baripada.
Due to the activities of Graham there was tension from 1981.  The then 
collector Fanibhushan Dash reported concern over conversion and rising 
tension among Santhals.  Every year tribes perform Maker Sankranti (Jan 
14) and Raja Sankranti (Jun 14-16) with pump and ceremony.  But every 
year this was being opposed by converted Christians by performing 
ploughing etc.,  which is a act of sin in those Sankranti as per their 
tradition.  This year also that happened.  So administration was 
compelled since 10-15 years to deploy police force during those Hindu 
functions in that locality every year.
And therefore self declared leadership was developed in each episode of 
group clashes (Regd.  FIR, cases are there in every year against each 
other) between converted and non-converted Santhals and Kolhas.  Which 
Dara Singh assumed leadership of Santhals, Shyam Sundar Marandi, Ragadi 
Sara and youngster Salman Marandi took the leadership of Santhal 
This area is a traditional stronghold of Congress.  Two eminent 
ministers Sri Jaydev Jena (Mass Education) and Niranjan Pattnaik 
(Industry & Mines) belong to the same sub-division Anandpur, in this J. 
B.  Pattnaik ministry.  Dara Singh having many warrants against him in 
police stations of the district was still active under the political 
safe-arm of this ministers, which is a known fact.  This fact is going 
to be covered in the name of Bajrang Dal, conspired by the congress 
ministry, by police DGP's statement.  Madhavrao Scindia instigated the 
villagers to tell the name of Bajrang Dal.  He also assured the backing 
of congress during his recent tour of the affected area.  During last 
four years almost all disturbances of Keonjhar district is only because 
of the two infighting groups of the ruling party led by two ministers, 
is an open secret.  For reference, Mr Niranjan Pattnaik happens to be a 
close relative of the chief minister Mr Janaki Ballava Pattnaik and Mr 
Jaydev Jena belongs to the camp deputy Chief Minister, Basanta Biswal.
That dreadful Night:
During the third week of Jan 1999, Graham Steins and his 10 preachers, 
including Australian Gilbert Venj, two lectures from Cuttack namely 
Subhankar Ghosh and Rajendra Swain, and others from Baripada, conducted 
a massive tour and propaganda in that area, conducting village meetings,
showing films regarding Jesus Christ, and mobilising many people to be 
converted.  It resulted an undercurrent of protest and tension among the
Santhals.  The usual process of conversion the 'jungle camp' started 
from 20th inside the temporary thatched house constructed specially for 
the converts.  In the midday of 22nd, the conversion of 56 families and 
the declaration of further target of converting 200 camp mates on 24th 
spread fire of revolt among the Santhals very rapidly in many adjacent 
villages.  Many angry Santhals and Kolhas gathered in that area in the 
midnight as a suo motto eruption of their anger of last 18 years, when 
the jungle camp was sleeping.  The angry mob targeted the vehicles 
ORM-1208 and ORM-952, which carried the preachers conducting the massive
tour, started damaging them.  By this time Graham, who was sleeping 
inside ORM-1208, covered with bundles of dry straw, woke up and 
threatened the mob with pistol firing.  Seeing the pistol the mob took 
it as a challenge and attacked him with arrow and finally burnt the 
vehicle.  The dry bundles of straw made it easy to burn the vehicle and 
difficult for Graham Steins to come out with his two sons, resulting the
fearful death of all of them.
And many questions:
1- Whether the organisers of Jungle camp in formed the authority about 
the camp or not?
2- Jungle camp going on and no police protection, why?
3- Police deployment in every Raja Sankranti and Makar Sankranti but why
not during the jungle camp
4- Only Graham was attacked and not the church or the other Christians, 
5- No local leader and jungle camp mates came for rescue? 
6- Why the mob was not opposed?
7- Where the other preachers were, doing what?
8- As per the Christians 20 to 80 persons came to attack, which can be 
countered easily by the jungle camp mates, which did not happen, why? 
9- Why only ORM-1208 was covered with dray straw?
10- The driver of other vehicle ORM-952 not inside, why?
11- If people left for jungles (as per Christians) and others were 
inside their closed house, then why the mob did not attack anybody 
having a free hand for that?
12- Nobody on behalf of the Christian rushed to the police station, why?
13- Why police reached the spot the next day morning, 9 hours after the 
14- Is there any previous groupism between the local and non Indian 
15- Is there any support for this incident from the local Christian 
leaders due to leadership, administrative and financial questions? 
16- According to medical authorities Keonjhar and Mayurbhanj district
are not at all in the map of leprosy prone area of the state.  Then why 
Graham started a leprosy center there?
17- Whether service to Santhals disconnect them socially from other 
Santhals that hurt them since last long?
18- Is it an international conspiracy of creating communal disturbances 
involving Christians and pressurising from western white countries to 
dethrone this Vajpayee led Government?
19- Whether English media particularly the New Indian Express is a handy
work of that conspiracy and so giving such preplanned baseless statement
involving VHP & Bajrang Dal ?
20- Though law and order is a state chapter, why some political groups 
and leaders blaming the central Government?  Are they acting as per the 
21- As a part of that conspiracy the state administration is not acting 
as per the Freedom of Religion Act (1969), Orissa.
22- Also the police authority acting to that international conspiracy, 
stating the involvement of Bajrang Dal without visualising the spot and 
the incident.
1- Almost all national and regional political parties have condemned 
this cruel act including BJP, BJD and Congress.
2- Leftist wagon and Janata Dal condemned this act but traditionally 
blamed RSS, VHP & Bajrang Dal.
3- RSS, VHP & Bajrang Dal having no organisational works in that area, 
then why to blame them?
4- Many organisations also condemned this heinous crime, of which state 
RSS, VHP & Bajrang Dal are in the fore front.
A special report by Shri Subash Chouhan,
RASTRADEEP, Narisangha Sadan Chhak, Buxi Bazar, Cuttack 753 001. Tel: 
(0671) 60 1552.
This is the National Debate on System Reform.       debate@indiapolicy.org 
Rules, Procedures, Archives:            http://www.indiapolicy.org/debate/ 

This is the National Debate on System Reform.       debate@indiapolicy.org
Rules, Procedures, Archives:            http://www.indiapolicy.org/debate/