[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Aha! One more attack on good sense

Dear SS

You are right in pointing out the misinformation.  However, people on this list 
cannot simply write Opinion columns, they have to be invited to write such 
columns by the Editors concerned, and that is unlikely in the current structure 
of newspapers everywhere in the world.

What you and I (and others on this list) can do is:

1.  Write Letters to the Editor pointing out such stupidities, so that the 
writer of such articles loses face (at least in the eyes of the Editor, even if 
our Letters are not published).  As a matter of fact, I am quite hopeful that, 
as long as we have a Press which is relatively free, such Letters will be 

2.  Try and ensure that at least those Indians who have access to the Internet 
get access to the discussions which are taking place in lists such as ours.


Professor Prabhu Guptara
Director, Organisational and Executive Development
Wolfsberg Executive Development Centre
(a subsidiary of UBS AG)
CH-8272 Ermatingen
Tel: + 41.71.663.5605
Fax: +41.71.663.5590
e-mail: prabhu.guptara@ubs.com

______________________________ Reply Separator _________________________________
Subject: Aha! One more attack on good sense
Author:  sabhlok (sabhlok@almaak.usc.edu) at nyuxuu
Date:    01.08.98 10:31

I am perpetually amazed. How is it that this man called Marx, dead so long 
ago, cannot ever leave us in peace in India! He is born again and again in 
various avtaars. He wrote one essay on India which I think (I might be 
wrong here) somehow spawned this "dependicia school," with its roots 
somewhere in an imaginary world.
Just finished reading a completely misguided article, full of wrong 
statistics and wrong conclusions, as an Opinion in Hindustan Times. Check 
        by Ash Narain Roy
Let me point out some of the atrocious statements, just to illustrate how 
these folk distort reality to the hilt.
* "But is the world a better place? Has free market capitalism brought 
... prosperity to all corners of the globe?"
Prosperity - Amazing distortion of data! Of course!! free market 
capitalism (if and wherever practiced) has brought enormous prosperity. 
Data are resounding on this basic correlation. 
* "As more and more countries are suffering from global market meltdown 
and currency volatility,"
Unbelievable!! a "global melt down" is taking place, according to Roy. A 
meltdown of India is surely taking place since the last 50 years (before 
that I am ignoring its economy since India was not independent). But the 
globe? Never saw any trace of it anywhere! "currency volatility" - whose 
currency is volatile? That of USA? And what is the alternative? Fix all 
exchange rates for ever till the entire world gets distorted? Why are 
people afraid of fluctuating ERs?  Daily stock market movements are also 
representative of volatility. Is that something bad? Markets will always 
lead to volatility as they absorb new information. That is the process of 
price formation. 
* "In the last 500 years no country has achieved high levels of social and 
economic development following a road of dependency and subordination to 
external forces. There is no such thing as subordinated development."
There was no difference in the development of nations 500 years ago. All 
nations were roughly at the same level of development. Then, 250 years 
ago, the Industrial revolution began and the differences began to mount. 
Mercantalism gave way to laissez-faire. The USA, which gave itself the 
most free-enterprise Constitution ever devised by man, steadily began its 
inexorable climb to the top of the world. The US had hardly any colonies. 
It did not need to "exploit" the rest of the world to reach where it is 
today. {sure, it was 'lucky' in getting resources, but USSR also has huge 
resources, as has Bihar and India in general. It was the system that made 
the difference.}
About the other part: no nation can succeed through subordination. Of 
course, that is obvious. But is it the claim of Mr. Ash Narain that India 
has been subordinate to someone in the past 50 years? Then why is India 
worse off today (in comparison to its position vis-a-vis the USA) than it 
was 50 years ago, just to take a simple example? Nations do not need 
colonies to grow rich. Nations need free-enterprise. And its corollary: 
free-trade (to the extent possible). Data is clear beyond any iota of 
doubt on these basic trends.
I am really getting sick of the misinformation being dished out to Indian 
readers by these so-called 'intellectuals' of India. When will correct 
facts and positions be shown to the people? 
Will people on this list please start writing "Opinions"  for the Indian 
newspapers and launch a blitzkreig against this gross misinformation 
campaign that has been running in India for the past 50 years? We cannot 
let these Ashes and others get away with murder. They are ruining all hope 
of the revival of India. First the arguments that "economic reform causes 
corruption," and now, "free enterprise causes poverty and inequality." 
The poor Indian reader is totally confused in the absence of strong and 
focused attacks on this false propaganda. 
This is a posting to India_Policy Discussion list: india_policy@cine.net 
Rules, Procedures, Archives:     http://www.indiaconsult.com/indiapolicy/ 

This is a posting to India_Policy Discussion list: india_policy@cine.net
Rules, Procedures, Archives:     http://www.indiaconsult.com/indiapolicy/